MenAlive.com - irritable male syndrome, men's health and male menopause
Live Long and Well

The Irritable Male Syndrome: Managing the 4 key Causes of Male Depression and Aggression  The Whole Man Program: Reinvigorating Your Body, Mind, and Spirit After 40  Surviving Male Menopause  Male Menopause - check out Jed's workshop tapes and CDs
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv

Men's Love and Hate for Women

Column on the Irritable Male Syndrome (IMS)

Copyright © 2004 by Jed Diamond

Need help now?

I offer two options for help: (1) Personal counseling with me and (2) My new internet-based program.

  1. If you think you may need counseling help, feel free to contact me at Jed@MenAlive.com. (If you're new, be sure and respond to my spamarrest notice so I receive your e-mail.) I offer immediate help in my office or by phone.
  2. Are you a man who is overstressed, frustrated, and angry? Are you a woman who walks on egg shells afraid you will set him off? Is your relationship suffering? This program is for you. To get help CLICK HERE.
Click here to check out Jed's IMS Aliveguide




What is IMS?







What are they saying about Jed's new book?







Bring your Irritable Male back to life






 

In his book, Misogyny: The Male Malady, anthropology professor David D. Gilmore, says, "That men love and hate women simultaneously and in equal measure, that most men need women desperately, and that most men reject this driving need as both unworthy and dangerous."

Gilmore explores cultures from Western Europe to the Middle East, from the jungles of South America to the remote uplands of New Guinea, from preliterate tribal peoples to modern Americans. He looks at ancient and modern cultures and all those in between. He finds that in all places and in all times, there has been a tendency for men to fear and hate women.

Obviously this isn't the case of all men. Though this ambivalence is played out in all societies, individual men differ in the degree to which it affects them. For some of us the fear and rage are extreme. For others, we control it well and it seeps out only at times of change and stress. The fear and hatred can be expressed in thoughts and actions as well as through art, writing, poetry, and fantasy. We can see it in the works of many famous writers including Swift, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Strindberg, Tolstoy, Pound, D.H. Lawrence, and Norman Mailer.

After offering hundreds of pages of quite interesting and compelling evidence to lend credence to his thesis Gilmore concludes that this "love/hate" dynamic is rooted in men's unique dependency on women. He points out that in most cultures men depend upon their mothers and later their wives for food preparation, domestic care, emotional support and nurturing.

He also reminds us that in all cultures and in all times, men are dependent on women to mate with them, carry a child within her body, give birth to the baby, and feed and care for him until he is able to live on his own. Men depend on their wives, he tells us for procreation and continuity. "To bear the sons who will assure them a measure of immortality, protect them in war, care for them in their dotage, validate their masculinity, and assist them in their god-given task of continuing their line."

We love them for what they can give us, but are also frightened at the degree of our dependency. "So man must cling helplessly to woman as a shipwrecked sailor to a lifeboat in choppy seas," says Gilmore. "He desperately needs her as his salvation from all want and from oblivion; his dependency is total and desperate. But, and here's the rub, man must also separate from woman to achieve anything at all. He must overcome his desire to regress to infantile symbiosis with her if he is to be accountable as a man."

I've found this dynamic has played out in most of my intimate relationships. Understanding it has helped me be less demanding on my mate and less hard on myself. What's your experience been like? Drop me a note and let me know. I'd like to hear your thoughts and reactions.

Sign up for Jed's exciting, informative, up-to-date men's health newsletter, and receive a FREE copy of Jed's booklet "Why Men Die Sooner and Live Sicker: And What You Can Do About It."
Sign me up!

This article first appeared on Gordon Clay's MenStuff Web site, http://www.menstuff.org/


Need help now?

I offer two options for help: (1) Personal counseling with me and (2) My new internet-based program.

  1. If you think you may need counseling help, feel free to contact me at Jed@MenAlive.com. (If you're new, be sure and respond to my spamarrest notice so I receive your e-mail.) I offer immediate help in my office or by phone.
  2. Are you a man who is overstressed, frustrated, and angry? Are you a woman who walks on egg shells afraid you will set him off? Is your relationship suffering? This program is for you. To get help CLICK HERE.
Click here to check out Jed's IMS Aliveguide

Mission:
MenAlive seeks to enrich men's relationships with themselves, their families, and their communities.

Vision:
MenAlive focuses on male menopause as a critical bridge to the second half of life. We focus on the Irritable Male Syndrome and men and depression, to prepare men to cross that bridge. We address the hormonal, physical, psychological, interpersonal, sexual, nutritional, economic, social, ecological, and spiritual aspects of men's health and act as an influential source of timely information, resources, products and community centered events on male menopause and men's health, for men and the women who love them.

Home | Irritable Male | Male menopause | Male Depression | For Women | Books, tapes | About Jed Diamond | Blog | Other Resources | E-mail Jed

Copyright © 1998-2005 Jed Diamond and Bert H. Hoff | WebMaster Bert H. Hoff, creator of MenWeb and Men's Voices quarterly.